Mott Community College Board of Trustees Hires New Law Firm, Fifth Since 2023

The Mott Community College Board of Trustees voted to hire Dickinson Wright PLLC as the board’s new legal representatives during a special meeting on November 9.

Trustees John Daly III, PhD, Santino Guerra, Art Reyes, and Wendy Wolcott voted in favor while Board Chair Jeffrey Swanson and Trustee Candice Miller voted against. Trustee Kenyetta Dotson was absent.

“They’re (Dickinson Wright) very detail-oriented, well-rounded, time management they were under 30 minutes (in their presentation), they nailed all the questions, they have other people for backups, very knowledgeable,” Wolcott said.

An initial motion to hire Miller, Canfield, Paddock & Stone, PLC as the new firm representing the board failed 3-3, with Wolcott joining Swanson and Miller in opposition. The board also considered proposals from current representatives Butzel Long, P.C., Fausone & Grysko, PLC, Whitehead Law Counsel, PLLC, and Miller Johnson Attorneys during the meeting. The presentations from firms are available in the recording of the meeting.

Dickinson-Wright will be the board’s fifth firm they’ve hired as legal counsel since 2023. The board fired Amberly Brennan as attorney in 2023. The board then hired William Brickley as its attorney, a controversial decision because of Brickley’s connection to then-Board Chair Andy Everman. Brickley publicly resigned in late 2024 after raising conflict of interest concerns over a real estate transaction between a relative of a former board member and then-interim president (now president) Shaunda Richardson-Snell. Sean FitzGerald took over in 2025 publicly resigned but was later also terminated by the board after he’d resigned in June of that year.

Butzel Long, primarily represented at board meetings by Carey DeWitt, had served as legal counsel on an interim basis since 2025 and was among the firms board members considered during the special meeting. Swanson and Miller both spoke in favor of retaining them, but the firm did not have the support of the rest of the board.

“I personally picked Butzel Long,” Swanson said. “I’ve worked with them, they’ve done well for us over the past two years. Loyalty means a little bit here too.”

“I think he did an excellent job whenever we had any sort of investigations or anything he was completely thorough and honest with us,” Miller said.

The board has faced criticisms from the public during public comments at times for an over-reliance on legal counsel during meetings. Quentin Groce, a Flint resident who just finished in third place for the two open spots on Mott’s board, spoke during the special meeting and encouraged the board to change that practice.

“Specifically, what came up time and time again (while talking to voters) is how the board is conducting its business,” Groce said, noting that he was happy the board was conducting interviews with law firms and making their decision in public. “I’ve attended many of these meetings over the past couple of years and I’ve watched a habit take hold. Under prior board leadership, many questions were handed directly to counsel and this kind of set a precedent that has outlasted that leadership that started it and it has grown. In recent meetings, I’ve watched the current counsel speak freely and offer his own opinions more than once as if he held a seat at the table. Not because a trustee asked, but because the door had been left open. Asking for the advice of counsel is always appropriate, but the board’s attorney is not a trustee. Counsel has no vote. (Counsel) wasn’t elected by anyone in the district and shouldn’t hold the floor unless the board directly gives it to them. Voters can hold each trustee accountable at the ballot box, but they can’t do so with counsel.”

Among the primary concerns for board members was cost and process. Hiring a firm publicly and going through a more standard process of accepting and receiving bids from firms was a step toward proper processes again. Daly, whose term on the board ends at the end of the year, shared hope that settling on a firm will also allow the board to reduce the college’s bills for legal services.

“We’ve gotta change our ways,” Daly said. “We have got to pare down the legal costs. Whoever it is that’s selected, we have got to use that tool selectively. We cannot drag this in every time, every meeting. In my opinion, if this was our own personal money, we sure as hell wouldn’t spend it like this.”

Flint Weekly Newsletter Masthead

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to catch up on all of our headlines every Wednesday.