A New Administration in Flint Brings Opportunities for Transparency and a Fresh Start

My biggest takeaway from the results of Flint’s Mayoral election is simple: Mayor-Elect Tonya Burns was underestimated. And anyone who has watched her representing Flint’s Sixth Ward, and really the entire city, on City Council over the past four years already knows that was a mistake.

In a pre-election interview, Burns described herself to me as Flint’s, “Councilwoman at large.” There’s an easy explanation for that — she picks up her phone. Much like former Councilman Eric Mays, in her political career Burns has built trust among her supporters due to her responsiveness whether the people calling on her for help lived in her ward or not mixed with a tough or even confrontational approach that many constituents felt met the urgency of what they needed assistance for.

It’s politics, and everyone including Burns has detractors too, but the coalition she built within the city that propelled her to the election win was truly impressive. Now, she has to govern. She will be sworn in as Mayor during a ceremony at 2 p.m. on November 24 at City Hall and officially assume office on December 1.

Governing is always the tricky part, especially for any politician who builds their reputation on being a powerful dissenting voice. For years, Burns was a frequent critic of former Mayor Sheldon Neeley and his administration, but she also often found herself out-voted in Council decisions during her tenure, so she didn’t have the power to force changes she was advocating for. Now, she will be the one setting the city’s agenda and wielding power. Based on her introductory press conference at least, a foundational part of her administration will be centered on correcting something the Neeley administration was frequently criticized for: transparency, or a lack thereof.

“This was always the people’s campaign,” Burns said. “We didn’t have the most money but what we had was the most people. I’m going to work to bring this community together, with integrity, with honesty, and with transparency. That is my goal and I’m not going to waver from it.”

Transparency as an Election Deal Breaker

At a Flint City Council meeting last July, there was a moment that perfectly encapsulated why the Neeley Administration had a problem. Burns and other members of the Council had, for weeks, been asking for detailed budget information related to the Mays Senior Center. Phillip Moore, who Neeley appointed as the city’s finance director in 2023, shared a spreadsheet that had three cells and three dollar amounts on it, with no context for what any of those dollar figures meant. So essentially, useless information that in no way answered what Council asked for.

It has long been obvious that Neeley and some members of City Council don’t trust each other. But, whoever is most to blame for that impasse, fiduciary oversight is the primary role of Council. Asking budgetary questions, especially related to senior center funding that had been controversial, is perfectly within the bounds of what the administration should be willing, able, and expected to provide to Council whether they like individual members or not. Neeley’s representative in front of the Council couldn’t or wouldn’t. That’s a failure. And that relatively small-scale public interaction, to me, lends credibility to bigger complaints about transparency issues.

It’s easy to Monday Morning Quarterback an election loss, of course. There are probably dozens of reasons people can point to that explain Neeley losing and Burns winning. First and foremost, we are in a bad economy, and incumbents from the federal level all the way down to local races are often punished in bad economic times whether they’re the ones pulling the levers of those conditions or not. I think it’s probably true that general economic anxiety played a role in Neeley’s loss.

Six people in green vests and hard hats digging in a pile of dirt
Mayor Sheldon Neeley (center) championed several community projects over the summer, including the opening of the St. John Street Neighborhood Memorial Park. (Photo: Patrick Hayes)

But there are two core, specific issues where the Neeley Administration’s lack of transparency hurt his re-election chances among some voters.

1. ARPA Dollars: The city of Flint received nearly $95 million in American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funding from the federal government in 2021, with the end of 2026 as the deadline to spend it within several qualifying categories. The city has a web page with information about programs and initiatives some of those dollars have been spent in. That hasn’t stopped conspiracies from flying about where those funds have gone, whether or not they’ve been misspent, and who is to blame. Conspiracies flourish when inadequate information is provided to squelch them, and in this case, the publicly available information is definitely inadequate.

As a resident and observer of how ARPA dollars were spent, these were my two big criticisms.

First, Council and residents weren’t given as much of a voice in how those dollars were allocated as many would’ve liked, and the reporting and impact of what those spent dollars have done for the community is not visible and easy to find (the web page is bare bones at best). A transparent approach would’ve included collaboration with Council Reps in each ward to host input sessions (even and perhaps especially with Council reps the administration found difficult to work with), creation of a spending plan from those sessions, and then accurate and detailed reporting on timelines, progress, and impact from the initiatives that resulted. We simply don’t have that information in a way that is easy to access and digest.

Secondly, the approach to spending those dollars was wrong but also consistent with Flint’s history. I love Flint, but Flint has immense problems with everything from blight to aging infrastructure to lack of jobs and economic opportunity and all of the sub-issues associated with those things. Getting an influx of $95 million is a lot of money, but nowhere near enough to make a dent in all of the problems decades of disinvestment here have caused. My preference would be to simply pick one thing and throw nearly all of the money at it. For example, putting $95 million toward blight and demolition wouldn’t completely fix that issue, but it would certainly go a long way. And the downstream effect of significantly reducing blight would potentially create positive impacts on other things (improved public safety and public health, new economic development opportunities, etc.). Instead, and the city has done this often across multiple administrations, we used a piecemeal approach with an influx of federal dollars, where a lot of different areas received little influxes of funding but not nearly enough to make a dramatic or visible enough impact in any one specific area. People need to notice changes in their day-to-day lives to believe government is effective, and the peanut butter approach to spending those dollars may have created some good things, but not enough to create a belief that the money had been effectively spent. So the narrative becomes, “Well, the ARPA dollars didn’t do anything” even if there are some tangible things it did.

Largely, I just think ARPA spending was hasty or not fully thought out. For example, the renovation of the historic Haskell Community Center is a cool project. It’s a unique, historic building and as a matter of principle I am always on the side of preserving our history and reusing old buildings. It received ARPA dollars. It is also located about two miles from Berston Fieldhouse, which is undergoing a major multimillion dollar renovation and also received ARPA dollars. So we will have two renovated community centers within close proximity to each other while there are areas on the city’s eastside, southside, and westside that are starved for more community spaces for young people.

Public input and thorough planning and reporting on spending and results would’ve helped reduce criticisms that exist of how ARPA funds were used or not used.

2. Pipe Replacement: This one is pretty simple. In August, Neeley and the state of Michigan announced that all lead service line replacements in Flint had been completed. In September, Burns noted that there are still known addresses that have lead service lines. So we have an outgoing administration who says the work is done and an incoming administration who says it isn’t. Clearly, many voters believe the latter. But at what point can residents just expect an honest answer to what should be a simple question? “Are the lead service lines replaced?” shouldn’t be political. It is yes or no.

Along with the lingering health issues created by the water crisis, perhaps the most damaging is the long-term lack of trust in governmental institutions to provide honest answers. Lead service line replacement seems like the most obvious opportunity for city, state, and federal officials to rally around honesty and transparency and tell residents exactly what the status of Flint’s water system is. Over a decade after the water crisis was first inflicted on residents by failed governmental oversight, we still can’t get a straight answer to a simple question.

The Old Ways Don’t Work

This is not so much a commentary on Neeley as it is on the old way of doing local politics. The thinking is basically this: an election approaches, and an incumbent does a bunch of photo ops and ribbon cuttings and throws some asphalt down on streets so those provide fresh memories as voters head to the polls. We do have goldfish brains and only tend to remember the immediate past, so it makes sense why that playbook has worked for so long all over the counry.

Neeley definitely employed parts of that strategy, with a bunch of roads hastily paved late in the summer and early fall, a ribbon cutting at the new St. John Street Neighborhood Memorial Park, some keys to the city handed out, and a few streets renamed in honor of some of our legendary past and present residents. And none of those are bad things. But I also don’t think that’s enough to win elections anymore.

Burns’ popularity is due in part to her social media presence. She talks to voters regularly through her Facebook page. She explains her reasoning for supporting or not supporting things. Neeley’s team was active in posting content to the city’s social media pages, but that’s not the same. It’s polished content, and people don’t trust polished content anymore. They want people to talk to them authentically. If there’s one trend in all types of elections nationwide that seems universal it is that the most successful candidates are the ones who can comfortably be themselves on social media platforms. You have to combine it with tried and true things like door-knocking and being a physical presence in your community of course, but I don’t think you can do one without the other anymore in competitive races and reach a maximum number of voters. Burns simply controlled more of the narrative in this election because she created a public-facing platform where she regularly talked directly to residents and voters.

Neeley’s Legacy

Neeley has held elected office in some capacity in Flint for more than 20 years, and that doesn’t happen without a strong contingent of residents trusting his stewardship of the city.

Neeley seemed especially adept at remembering residents and their stories. He’s been known for sending hand-written notes to residents for a variety of reasons, including when families experience a death or a loss, or even just out of the blue. My wife has never met him but received one in a non-election year, just introducing himself and encouraging her to reach out to the city if she ever needed assistance. We still don’t really know why she received it, but we heard from other people who had received similar communications from him at times that were not at all self-serving – it’s common to hear from politicians when they want you to go vote for them, but less common at a time when they seemingly aren’t courting you for support. I don’t know what the strategy or thinking was behind it, but it was certainly unique.

My son hosts a yearly 1-on-1 basketball tournament in our driveway for his birthday. We always have a few neighborhood passersby who come watch. During the COVID-19 pandemic, we had to do it virtually, over Zoom, with kids playing “HORSE” and calling their shots then pointing their camera to their rim to see if they made it or not. We couldn’t hand out our annual trophy since we weren’t gathered in person. I had a friend who worked at City Hall at the time who mentioned it to the Mayor. He gave her a signed certificate we could mail to the winner.

I also watched him speak at a Mott Park neighborhood meeting, and he recognized a woman in the audience who he’d worked with when he was on City Council to remove a blighted industrial property that was a nuisance in the Sixth Ward. It had been years since they’d worked on it together, but he acknowledged her and her passion for making her neighborhood better in a way that was clearly meaningful to her.

Any politician brings positives and negatives to the table, but even in the midst of things I truly disagreed with the administration on, I also always understood why Neeley’s supporters felt and feel strongly about him.

There were two game-changing initiatives under his administration that I think will be felt positively for generations of Flintstones for years to come.

Flint’s drastic population loss over the years has always had a major impact on the city’s finances. Flint in its heyday had over 200,000 people, and with that a lot of city employees. The population and tax base dwindled, but the obligations to retiree pensions and other municipal costs didn’t shrink with it. That caused year challenges, projected budget shortfalls, and other potentially ruinous financial issues.

Flint isn’t in that position anymore, because in 2023, the city and the state of Michigan agreed on a $220 million state budget provision that brought Flint’s pension system up to minimum state funding standards. That’s all boring accounting nerd speak, but it truly has been a major relief for the city’s finances.

Neeley also deserves credit for championing the Rx Kids program, which launched in Flint in 2024 and provides monthly cash payments for all babies born in the city. The early results, particularly in reducing miscarriages, preterm births, low birthweight, and NICU admissions, are staggeringly positive. It is truly easing burdens on families and also bringing healthier Flint babies into our community.

There are plenty of things that, as a resident, are fair to be critical of. His staff turnover in key positions at City Hall was significant. The city had and lost some talented employees consistently under his watch, and that was immensely frustrating.

The Saginaw Street historic brick relaying project has also, frankly, been a disaster. The bricks are a beloved part of Flint’s lore, and restoring them should’ve been the easiest slam dunk. Instead, the communication around road closures and other inconveniences for the project was extremely detrimental for small businesses downtown and the construction itself was so sloppily done that sections of the street already look worse than they did prior to redoing them.

Burns’ Opportunities

Here’s where I think Burns has the greatest opportunity as Mayor: her experience on Council. She was often out-voted. She often asked tough questions that deserved answers and the Administration didn’t provide adequate ones. That doesn’t mean Burns was necessarily always in the right in those imbalances, but treating an elected Council member as if her questions on behalf of constituents don’t need to be addressed was the wrong approach. Burns experienced that on one extreme of the power dynamic and has a chance to right it and build a better working relationship between her administration and City Council than we’ve seen over the course of the last two or three administrations.

I hope, through her leadership and with a significantly different makeup on the City Council with seven new representatives, she is able to lead with openness. I don’t expect elected mayors and city councilors to always be on the same page. There can and should be disagreement and debate. But it can be healthy debate, and if she can set that standard from the beginning of her tenure, that will be a huge win for the city and our residents.

I also hope that leadership extends into City Hall. Staff turnover is detrimental to Flint’s ability to provide high-level service to residents. We’ve undoubtedly lost good, talented employees, and I hope that trend stops. Mayors are not elected to be experts on every aspect of city governance. They are elected because voters trust their judgement enough to allow them to decide who fills those important roles. Burns earned the trust of a majority of voters and can repay it by finding top-notch leaders with expertise and empowering them to lead their departments competently.

It is unfair to expect any single person to be able to change the many things in need of fixing in the city, so I don’t expect Burns to have a magic wand. But a new administration always does bring hope for a fresh start, new talents, and new ways of doing things. I’m looking forward to watching Burns articulate her vision for how the city should function and bringing aboard the right people to implement it.

Flint Weekly Newsletter Masthead

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to catch up on all of our headlines every Wednesday.